Greatest Taylor Sheridan Shows of All Time
1923 or Yellowstone
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
In the sprawling saga of Taylor Sheridan's television universe, where does the soul of the frontier lie — in the gritty pastures of 'Yellowstone' or the historic tumult of '1923'? Here we have a classic showdown of legacy versus new frontier, pitting the raw, modern-day ranch battles of the Dutton family against the brutal, early 20th-century challenges their ancestors faced. In this battle, the stakes couldn't be higher: it's not just about who wins, but about which era of Sheridan's storytelling resonates deepest with fans, asking us to ponder whether our hearts belong to the untamed present or the wild, storied past.
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Fan FAQs
What makes 1923 so popular?
1923 dives deep into the Dutton family's earlier days, giving fans a captivating look at their struggles and triumphs. The historical angle plus a new cast has really resonated with those who love a good origin story.
Why do fans love Yellowstone?
Yellowstone nails that raw, intense portrayal of ranch life mixed with some heavy family drama. Plus, Kevin Costner leading the charge? It's no wonder fans are all over it!
Why is this matchup between Yellowstone and 1923 so close?
Fans are seriously torn! Yellowstone brings that gritty family drama vibe we all got hooked on, while 1923 has that historical depth and a fresh twist on the Dutton legacy. Both have huge appeals, just hitting different sweet spots for viewers.